by Chris Woodford. Last updated: August 23, 2016.
Wind turbines are like airplanes running
on the spot—spinning round but
going nowhere. They're serving a very useful purpose, however.
There's energy locked in wind and these giant propellers can
capture some of it and turn it instantly into electricity.
Have you ever stopped to wonder how wind turbines work? Let's take a
Photo: Left: A small wind farm in Colorado, United States. These are relatively small turbines: each one produces about 700kW of energy (enough to supply 225 homes). The turbines are 79m (260ft) high (from the ground to the very top of the rotors) and the rotors themselves are 48.5m (159ft) in diameter. The top part of each turbine (called the nacelle) rotates on the tower beneath so the spinning blades are always facing directly into the wind.
Photo by Warren Gretz courtesy of US Department of Energy/NREL (DoE/NREL).
How does a turbine generate electricity?
A turbine is a machine that spins around
in a moving fluid (liquid or
gas) and catches some of the energy passing by. All sorts of machines
use turbines, from jet engines to
plants and from diesel railroad locomotives to windmills. Even a
child's toy windmill is a simple form of turbine.
The huge rotor blades (propellers) on the front of a wind turbine
"turbine" part. As wind passes by, the kinetic energy
(energy of movement) it contains makes the blades spin around (usually
quite slowly). The
blades have a special curved shape so they capture as much energy from
the wind as possible.
Although we talk about "wind turbines," the turbine is only one of
the three main parts inside these giant machines. The second part is a gearbox whose gears convert the slow speed of the spinning blades into higher-speed
rotary motion—turning the drive shaft quickly enough to power the
The generator is the third main part of a
turbine and it's exactly like an enormous, scaled-up version of the dynamo on a bicycle. When you
ride a bicycle, the dynamo touching the back wheel spins around and
generates enough electricity to make a lamp light up. The same thing
happens in a wind turbine, only the "dynamo" generator is driven
by the turbine's rotor blades instead of by a bicycle wheel, and
the "lamp" is a light in someone's home dozens of miles away.
Read more in our main article about generators.
Photo: Head for heights! You can see just how big a wind turbine is compared to this
engineer, who's standing right inside the nacelle (main unit) carrying out maintenance. Notice how
the white blades at the front connect via an axle (gray—under the engineer's feet) to the gearbox and generator
behind (blue). Photo by Lance Cheung courtesy of US Air Force.
How does a wind turbine work?
- Wind (moving air that contains kinetic energy) blows toward the turbine's rotor blades.
- The rotors spin around slowly, capturing some of the kinetic energy from the wind, and turning the central drive shaft that supports them.
- The rotor blades can swivel on the hub at the front so they meet the wind at the best angle for harvesting energy.
- Inside the nacelle (the main body of the turbine sitting on top of the tower and behind the blades), the gearbox converts the low-speed rotation of the drive shaft (about 16 revolutions per minute, rpm) into high-speed (1600 rpm) rotation fast enough to drive the generator efficiently.
- The generator, immediately behind the gearbox, takes kinetic energy from the spinning drive shaft and turns it into electrical energy. A typical turbine generator will produce 1–2 megawatts (MW) of power at about 700 volts.
- Anemometers (wind-speed monitors) and wind vanes on the back of the nacelle provide measurements
about the wind speed and direction.
- Using these measurements, the entire top part of the turbine (the rotors and nacelle) can be rotated by a yaw motor, mounted between the nacelle and the tower, so it faces directly into the oncoming wind and captures the maximum amount of energy. If the wind speed rises too much, brakes are applied to stop the rotors from turning (for safety reasons). The brakes can also be applied for routine maintenance.
- The electric current produced by the generator flows through a cable running down through the inside of the turbine tower.
- A step-up transformer converts the electricity to about 50 times higher voltage so it can be transmitted efficiently to the power grid (or to nearby buildings or communities). If the electricity is flowing to the grid, it's converted to an even higher voltage (130,000 volts or more) by a substation nearby, which services many turbines.
- Homes enjoy clean, green energy.
- Wind carries on blowing past the turbine, but with lower speed and lower energy (for reasons explained below) and more
turbulence (since the turbine has disrupted its flow).
How turbines harvest maximum energy
If you've ever seen a wind turbine, you'll know that they are
absolutely gigantic and mounted on incredibly high towers. The bigger
the rotor blades, the more energy they can capture from the wind. The
giant blades (typically 70m or 230 feet in diameter, which is about 30
times the wingspan of an eagle) multiply the wind's force like
a wheel and axle, so even
a gentle breeze is enough to make the outer edges of the blades turn
around. Although the blades
rotate quite slowly, the inner axle and turbine rotate with greater
force—enough to turn the generator and make
electricity. (Wind turbines usually have anemometers—automatic speed
measuring devices—built into them and brakes that lock the
blades if the wind speed is too high.)
A typical wind turbine is 85 meters (280 feet) off the
ground—that's like 50 tall adults standing on one another's shoulders! There's
a good reason for this. If you've ever stood on a hill that's the
tallest point for miles around, you'll know that wind travels
much faster when it's clear of the buildings, trees, hills, and other
obstructions at ground level. So if you put a turbine's rotor
blades high in the air, they capture considerably more wind energy
than they would lower down. (If you make a wind turbine twice as high,
it will make roughly a third more power.) And capturing energy is what wind turbines
are all about.
Photo: This unusual Darrieus
"egg-beater" wind turbine rotates about a vertical axis, unlike a
normal propeller turbine.
Its main advantage is that it can be mounted nearer to the ground,
without a tower, which makes it cheaper and simpler to construct.
Photo by courtesy of US Department of Energy.
Since the blades of a wind turbine are rotating, they must have
kinetic energy, which they "steal" from the wind. Now
it's a basic law of physics (known as the conservation
of energy) that you can't make energy out of nothing, so the wind
must actually slow down slightly when it passes around a wind
turbine. That's not really a problem, because there's usually
plenty more wind following on behind! It is a problem if you want to
build a wind farm: unless you're in a really windy place, you have
to make sure each turbine is a good distance from the ones around it
so it's not affected by them.
Advantages and disadvantages of wind turbines
At first sight, it's hard to imagine why anyone would object to clean and green wind turbines—especially
when you compare them to dirty coal-fired plants and risky nuclear ones, but they do have some disadvantages.
One of the drawbacks of wind turbines is that they don't generate
anything like as much power as a conventional coal, gas, or nuclear plant. A typical
turbine has a maximum power output of 1–2 megawatts (MW), which is enough to run
500–1000 electric toasters simultaneously—and enough to supply about 500–1500 homes.
biggest offshore wind turbines can now make 6–8 megawatts and power up to 5500 homes.
In theory, you'd need about 1000–2000 turbines to make as much power as a
really sizable (2000 MW) coal-fired power plant or
a nuclear power station
(either of which can generate enough power to run a million toasters at the same time);
in practice, because coal and nuclear power stations produce energy fairly consistently
and wind energy is variable, you'd need rather more.
As we've just seen, you can't jam a couple of thousand wind turbines tightly together and expect them
to work effectively; they have to be spaced some distance apart
(typically 3–5 rotor diameters in the "crosswind" direction, between each turbine and the ones
either side, and 8–10 diameters in the "downwind" direction, between each turbine and the ones
in front and behind). Put these two things together and you arrive at the biggest and most
obvious disadvantage of wind power: it takes up an awful lot of space.
If you wanted to power an entire country with wind alone, you'd
need to cover an absolutely vast land area with turbines (the late, brilliant physicist David MacKay
explored these sorts of arguments at length).
You could still use the land between the turbines for farming; a typical wind farm removes only 3–10 percent
of land from production, and some of that is for access roads. You could mount turbines out at sea instead, but that would make it harder and more expensive to get the power ashore. Even onshore, connecting 1000 wind turbines to the power grid is obviously a bigger hurdle than wiring up a single, equivalent power plant; farmers and local communities often have objections to new power lines crossing their land.
On the plus side, wind turbines are clean and green: unlike coal
stations, once they're constructed, they don't make the carbon dioxide emissions that are
causing global warming or the
sulfur dioxide emissions that cause acid rain (a type of air pollution).
Once you've built them, the energy they make is limitless and (except for spare parts and maintenance) free.
That's even more of an advantage than it sounds, because the cost of running conventional power plants
is heavily geared to risky things like wholesale oil and gas prices and the volatility of world energy markets.
Wind turbines contain quite a bit of metal, and some
reinforced concrete to stop them falling over (a typical turbine has 8000 parts in total), so constructing them does have some environmental impact. (Remember that we're talking about a minimum of 1000–2000 turbines to replace a single power plant, so the amount of material isn't trivial.) Even so, looking at their entire operating lifespan, it turns out that wind turbines have among the lowest carbon dioxide emissions of any form of power generation, significantly lower than fossil-fueled plants, most solar installations, or biomass. Now nuclear power plants also have relatively low carbon dioxide emissions (roughly the same as wind turbines, measured over their lifespan). But wind turbines don't have the security and pollution problems many people associate with nuclear plants, and they're much quicker and easier to construct. They're also much cheaper, per kilowatt hour of power they produce: half the price of nuclear and two thirds the price of coal (according to 2009 figures quoted by Milligan et al). According to the Global Wind Energy Council, a turbine can produce enough power in 3–6 months to recover the energy used throughout its lifetime (constructing, operating, and recycling it).
- Very low carbon dioxide emissions (effectively zero once constructed).
- No air or water pollution.
- No fuel to pay for—ever!
- No environmental impacts from mining or drilling.
- Freedom from energy prices and political volatility of oil and gas supplies from other countries.
- Wind energy prices will become increasingly competitive as fossil fuel prices rise.
- Variable output—though that problem is reduced by operating wind farms in different areas.
- Large land take—though at least 90 percent of wind farm land can still be used for farming, and offshore turbines can be built at sea.
- Can't supply 100 percent of a country's power all year round, the way coal or nuclear can.
- Some environmental impact from the metal and concrete they contain.
- Loss of jobs for people working in mining and drilling.
- Can produce such cheap energy, at times, that they risk making conventional fossil fuel plants uneconomic.
Is wind the energy of the future?
It certainly has a part to play, but how big a part depends on where in the world you are and whether there are better alternatives suited to your local geography. In sunny Australia, for example, solar would probably make more sense.
In countries that have windy winters (when electricity demand is at its highest), wind turbines could be a
strong contender; on August 11, 2016, for example, wind turbines in (windy) Scotland produced
enough energy to power the whole country. Countries with lots of fossil-fueled plants and no plans to retire them soon might find investments in carbon capture and storage (scrubbing the carbon dioxide from the emissions of coal and other fossil plants) a wise option, though that remains a largely unproven technology. Ultimately, it's a political choice as well as a scientific one. In Germany, where people have strong opposition to nuclear power, there have been huge investments in wind energy. Denmark, another European country, plans to move to 100 percent renewable energy with a massive commitment to wind. Although China is investing heavily in wind power, it still makes about three quarters of its electricity from coal. In short, while the growth of wind power is impressive, it still plays a relatively small part, overall, in providing the world's electricity.
Chart: Which countries are making the most of their wind? This chart shows the ten countries with the most installed wind capacity as of 2015. It's no surprise to find big countries like China, the United States, and India topping the list, but it is interesting to see much smaller nations like Germany and Spain investing so heavily in wind. Drawn by Explainthatstuff.com with statistical data courtesy of the Global Wind Energy Council.
But what if the wind doesn't blow?
Some people worry that because wind is very variable, we might suddenly lose all our electricity and find
ourselves plunged into a "blackout" (a major power outage) if we rely on it too much.
The reality of wind is quite different. "Variable" does not mean unreliable or unpredictable. Wherever you live, your power comes from a complex grid (network) of intricately interconnected power-generating units (ranging from giant power plants to individual wind turbines). Utility companies are highly adept at balancing power generated in many different places, in many different ways, to match the load (the total power demand) as it varies from hour to hour and day to day. The power from any one wind turbine will fluctuate as the wind rises and falls, but the total power produced by thousands of turbines, widely dispersed across an entire country, is much more regular and predictable. For a country like the UK, it's pretty much always windy somewhere. As Graham Sinden of Oxford University's Environmental Change Institute has shown, low wind speeds affect more than half the country for only 10 percent of the time; for 60 percent of the time, only 20 percent of the UK suffers from low wind speeds; and only for one hour per year is 90 percent of the UK suffering low speeds (Sinden 2007, figure 7). In other words, having many wind turbines spread across many different places guarantees a reasonably steady supply of wind energy virtually all year round.
Photo: You can put lots of turbines together
to make a wind farm, but you need to space them out to harvest the
energy effectively. Combining the output from many wind farms
in many different areas produces a smoother and more predictable power supply.
This wind farm is at one of the world's windiest places: Altamont Pass, California, United States.
Photo by courtesy of US Department of Energy.
While it's true that you might need 1000 wind turbines to produce as much power as a giant coal or nuclear plant, it's also true that if a single wind turbine fails or stops turning, it causes only 1/1000th (0.1 percent) of the disruption you get when a coal or nuclear plant fails (which happens more often than you might think). It's also worth bearing in mind that wind is extremely predictable several days in advance so it's easy for power planners to take account of its variability as they figure out how to make enough power to meet expected demands.
Opponents of wind power have even suggested that it might be counter-productive, because we'd still need to have backup coal or nuclear plants (or some way of storing wind-generated electricity) for those times when there's not enough wind blowing. That would certainly be true if we made all our energy from one, single mega-sized wind turbine—but we don't! In reality, even countries that have large supplies of wind energy have plenty of other sources of power too; as long as wind power is making less than half of a country's total energy, the variability of the wind is not a problem. (Denmark, for example, makes 20 percent of its electricity—and meets 43 percent of its peak load—with wind; Eric Martinot's article "How is Denmark Integrating and Balancing Renewable Energy Today?" gives an excellent overview of how that country has managed to integrate huge amounts of wind power into its grid.)
If small is beautiful, micro-wind turbines—tiny
power generators perched on a roof or mast—should be the most attractive
form of renewable energy by far. Some manufacturers have pushed the
technology aggressively, hinting to consumers about big savings on
electricity bills and major benefits for the environment. The reality
is a little different: micro-turbines do indeed bring economic and
environmental benefits if they're sited in reliably windy areas, but
they're less helpful in towns and cities where buildings
make "energy harvesting" more of a challenge. So are micro-wind turbines
really worth the investment? How do they compare with their big brothers?
Photo: Micro power to the people! This small, mast-mounted Rutland Windcharger is designed to trickle-charge 12V and 24V batteries, such as those used in small boats, far from the grid. At a wind speed of 40–55 km/h (20–30 knots), it will produce a handsome 140–240 watts of power. At 20 km/h (10 knots), it produces a rather more modest 27 watts.
How micro-wind turbines compare
These figures are simply designed to give a rough comparison of the differences between
large-scale and micro-wind turbines. Bear in mind that there's a huge variety of micro-turbines.
||Tower roughly 80–100m (260–344ft) high.
||Roof, or mast typically ~10m (30ft) high.
||Up to 90m (300ft).
||1–8 megawatts (1000–8000 kilowatts).
||400–40,000 watts (0.4–40 kilowatts).
|Operates in wind speeds
||10–55mph (16–90 km/h).
||10–40mph (16–64 km/h).
||$1–2 million per MW.
|Provides power to
How to set up your own micro-wind turbine
If you want to build your own micro-wind turbine, what do you need?
Apart from the turbine itself, you also typically need a piece
of electrical equipment called an inverter (which converts the
direct-current electricity produced by the turbine's generator into
alternating current you can use in your home) and appropriate
electrical cabling. Your turbine will also need either a connection
into the grid supply or batteries to store the energy it produces.
Aside from the equipment, here are a few pointers worth bearing in mind:
- The best place to start is with a professional assessment of
your site's wind potential, which involves a series of measurements
with an anemometer. Remember that wind turbines generally work far better in
open, rural areas than mounted on rooftops in cities.
- Don't assume it will automatically be windy enough to make
the investment in a microturbine worthwhile: a recent UK study of
microturbines by Encraft found a mixed picture, with good
performance from the best-located turbines and the very worst
performing model (embarrassingly) not even producing enough
electricity to power its own electronics—in other words, using more
electricity overall than it produced. Some contribution to the environment!
- Depending on where you live, you will almost certainly need
planning consent for a wind turbine, so check that out carefully with your
local authority first.
- Sound out your neighbors before you start spending any money:
instead of turning your "local friends" into bitter enemies with your rooftop propeller, maybe you could persuade them to join you in a community green-energy venture?
- Remember that roof-mounted wind turbines could prove noisy
and cause problems with vibration.
- Don't forget that there are all kinds of other energy
technologies that might give a quicker and better return on your
investment and make more difference to the planet. Energy efficiency
measures (such as improved heat insulation) generally give the
quickest payback for least cost and make the most difference in the
short-term, and solar hot water systems work very well
almost anywhere. Ground-source heat pumps are also worth a look.
Photo: Although micro-wind turbines on homes have proved controversial, they definitely have their place. Here's the Rutland Windcharger from our top photo helping to charge the batteries in a go-anywhere, portable highway construction sign. It's getting help from the large flat solar panel mounted on top. This is a great example of how micro-wind turbines can be useful if you put them in the right place, at the right time.
My thanks to Prof. John Twidell for suggesting that I add this new material on the variability of wind power (a very broad, very simplified summary of the kind of arguments made in the papers by Michael Milligan et al and John Twidell, which you'll find listed in the references below).
Find out more
On this website
On other sites
- How wind turbines work: Ecotricity, the leading British wind energy company has a very informative website, with lots of photos showing how its numerous wind parks were constructed.
- Wind with Miller: A great introduction to wind energy from the Danish Wind Industry Association. This one's for younger readers.
- Guided tour on wind energy: A deeper introduction to wind energy for older readers, also from the Danish Wind Industry Association. Includes a detailed look at all the parts of a wind turbine and what they do.
Technical and journal articles
- How is Denmark Integrating and Balancing Renewable Energy Today? by Eric Martinot, January 2015.
- Wind: Physicist David MacKay looks at how much of a contribution wind power can realistically make to the UK's total energy needs in his book Sustainable Energy Without the Hot Air.
- Wind Power Myths Debunked by Michael Milligan et al, IEEE Power & Energy Magazine, November/December 2009. A clear, easy-to-understand explanation of how wind power can be integrated into a grid network.
- [PDF] Characteristics of the UK wind resource: Long-term patterns and relationship to electricity demand by Graham Sinden. Energy Policy, Volume 35, Issue 1, January 2007, Pages 112–127. This detailed paper studies wind power production over a period of 34 years at 66 different UK sites and debunks the myth that wind turbines are unproductive for much of the time.
- [DOC] Assessing Backup Requirements for Wind Power by John Twidell, Institute of Physics (IOP) Energy Group Newsletter, November 2010.
- [PDF] The Economics of Wind Energy by Søren Krohn et al, European Wind Energy Association, 2009. A comprehensive economic evaluation of the costs and benefits of wind power.
- Warwick Wind Trials: A detailed UK study of micro-wind carried out between 2006 and 2008.
- Mexico's Wind Farms Brought Prosperity, but Not for Everyone by Victoria Burnett. The New York Times, July 26, 2016. People who live near wind farms seldom share in their benefits, though that's equally true of other forms of power generation.
- Solar and Wind Energy Start to Win on Price vs. Conventional Fuels by Diane Cardwell. The New York Times, November 23, 2014. Renewable power is now competitive with (and sometimes cheaper than) coal and gas.
- A Tricky Transition From Fossil Fuel: Denmark Aims for 100 Percent Renewable Energy by Justin Gillis. The New York Times, November 11, 2014. What problems is Denmark likely to face as it moves toward its goal of 100 percent renewable energy?
- Sun and Wind Alter Global Landscape, Leaving Utilities Behind by Justin Gillis. The New York Times, September 13, 2014. Wind and solar are changing the economics of power production, prompting traditional electricity producers to rethink how they do business.
- Little Limit to the Amount of Wind Energy by Dave Levitan. IEEE Spectrum, September 2012. How much wind energy is there on Earth? Is there an upper limit? How much of humankind's energy could we really make from the wind?
- Windfarms do not cause long-term damage to bird populations, study finds by Severin Carrell. The Guardian, 12 April 2012. A major study confirms that birds are usually quite safe from wind turbines, though construction sites can sometimes pose a problem.
- Three steps to build a wind farm by David Shukman. BBC News, 15 August 2011. How do you build an offshore wind farm? This great interactive feature from the BBC explains all you need to know.
Need photos for a school project on wind power? Have a look at:
- US Department of Energy/National Renewable Energy Laboratory Photo Library: Enter the search term "wind turbine" and you'll find a couple of thousand photos of turbines. As works of a US Federal Government agency, some of these photos are in the public domain, but others (supplied by turbine manufacturers) are copyright restricted.
- Flickr: Wind turbines: Some Flickr photos are published under Creative Commons licences (allowing limited reuse under certain conditions); others are copyright images.
- Inside a wind turbine: A fascinating seven-minute tour of a turbine at Crystal Rig Wind Farm in Scotland by Fred Olsen Renewables.
- A reality check on renewables by Professor Sir David MacKay, YouTube, June 26, 2013. An eloquent introduction to renewable energy: if you want to use solar or wind, you need an awful lot of it to make any difference, and you can expect it to take up a vast land area. Wind is discussed at
8m 6s, where David concludes that if the UK wanted to produce all its energy from wind, it would need to cover half the country with wind farms.
If you liked this article...
You might like my new book, Atoms Under the Floorboards: The Surprising Science Hidden in Your Home, published worldwide by Bloomsbury.
More to explore on our website...